My second Sunday in Dresden, I attended the Evangelical Free Church which the church planting team is working with. Unpredictably, everything about the FeG felt comfortable and familiar. This was most surprising because the entire service was in German, and the church held its service in a modern reconstruction of an old ballroom. I could just feel the love of the community.  

After church, the bass player introduced himself to me and to Roger. I complimented his impeccable talent immediately and struggled in deciding whether or not to mention that I pretended to play the bass, compared to his talent. (For the record, I believe that I did). Jan was very friendly and well spoken, in English. After a short chat, he told Jeff that he would like to show us around Dresden. We gladly accepted the invite, expecting Jan to have a different perspective than Klaus.

Klaus had taken us to the old part of the city and explained its history. Jan took us out to what locals call the Switzerland of Saxony- beautiful gardens, rock formations, and scenic views of the Elbe River. Along the way, Jan happily answered all of my questions. I’m sure I wore him out with conversation. 

Surprisingly, Jan offered a perspective on Communism that I had not yet heard. He had been a young man during the time of Communism and became a Christian in the same year that the wall came down. I believed that he too would have a story of suffering. Instead, Jan said the limitations of Communism really pushed him creatively and mechanically. Not having access to anything from the west, or basic parts in some cases, Jan had to build things on his own. He wanted a computer, so he built one. If his bike needed a repair, he had to make his own pieces. Limitations helped him to grow intellectually. The German word for this state of being without is “mangel.” It means “shortage.”

As a school teacher, Jan said that he didn’t see this in the lives of teenagers today. He said that they were meant to be “consumers, not inventors.” Ultimately, Jan believed that the oppression produced good character and creativity that is lacking in modern culture.  

On the other hand, Jan didn’t speak positively of the DDR (Deutsche Democratic Republic). The system, in general, was terrible. People had nothing to gain by working hard, but they had a lot to lose if they didn’t. So, Jan and his friends made plans to escape the east and move to the west. They never went through with it, but the idea was tossed around a lot.

Jan wouldn’t say that Communism was good, but he didn’t seem to have the rough experience others spoke of. It may been a matter of perspective. Like Klaus, Jan had also ordered his Trabant car from the government. The wall came down before he got the car though. He shrugged and laughed when he said this, but I think most people would be pretty mad about waiting years for a car they would never receive. Like he said though, more important things were happening. In that same year the wall came down (1989), Jan heard and accepted the Gospel through, what I gather was, a revival meeting his friends had invited him to.

When Jan returned home, he joined a state/Lutheran church. Having new life, Jan had a hard time with the state church. People didn’t have a relationship with Jesus and didn’t know how to answer his questions. The state church did not preach or reflect the Gospel message, but Jan chose to stay and to do everything he could to change the church from the inside. He didn’t feel like leaving the church was the best option. 
Around that time period, however, he spent a year in the states- where he attended an Evangelical Free church. The difference was like night and day. He grew in his faith there and desired to be a part of a church like that in his home country. Frustrated with the state church, he joined the FeG (Freie Evangelische Gemeinden/Evangelical Free Church), when he returned to Germany. 

Jan’s Comparison of the German and American Church

Jan wrote a paper, comparing the Petri-Nikolai-Kirche (Church) of Freiberg with the Crystal Evangelical Free Church of Minneapolis, for an English course. He was happy to share his paper with me. Finding his comparison fascinating, I have posted some excerpts below. 

My experiences in Crystal Evangelical Free Church in Minneapolis and my long experience with the German system of state churches led me to the following questions which became the starting point for the project:

1. How do the fundamental differences of the American and German church systems influence individual churches?

2. Which differences and which common aspects can be seen in the work of the two individual churches?

For individual members, the German system is characterized by the following aspects: 

1. Baptism marks the beginning of membership. Since most of the people are baptized as infants, they become members of the church without a conscious decision about their own membership.

2. Besides offerings and donations, the churches major financial receipts are taxes and are imposed on the members by the state – similar to the states taxes.

3. Every member belongs to a local church according to her/his place of living. This placement is carried out by the state authorities. Every time a church member moves to a different home, the member has to register and is subsequently assigned to a local church. Only recently however, have there been new regulations established allowing members to change churches.

It is undoubtedly true that large numbers of church members have no personal relationship to their church. Tradition is the only reason for their membership.

The following questionnaire was completed by members of each congregation.

Question #1 demographics.  

Question #5 demographics. 

Asked for the reason for membership, it was option 2 in Freiberg (I am assigned to this church by place of living) and option 4 in Minneapolis (I like the services and other activities of this church) that were chosen by majorities.

Question #8 demographics. 

 Question #9 demographics.


Just as I had expected, almost all German interviewees are members of the church in Freiberg, while only about two thirds of the interviewees and Crystal Evangelical Church are members. Since I know from experience that it is quite unusual for Germans to attend worship services without being church members, one can assume that most of the 8% non-members attended the service as guests although they actually are members of another church.

One can clearly see that membership is interpreted differently in the two different systems. While it is mainly considered a traditional feature in Germany, which millions of German received as infants, it is connected to a clear statement of faith in the USA.

Question #10 demographics.  

Question #11 and #14 demographics.   

Question #17 demographics.   

While 88% of the American interviews read at least frequently, only 12% answered sometimes or rarely. A comparatively large group of Freibergians answered they read every day 28% and frequently 20%, while many more people then in Minneapolis use to read only sometimes 27% or rarely 25%.

Question #18 demographics. 

While not as much emphasis is put on baptism and loving one’s neighbor, much more importance is attached to developing a personal relationship, to prayer and to reading the Bible by the interviewees in Crystal Evangelical free Church. In Freiberg, all options scored relatively evenly. With this result, this last question of the questionnaire again seems to reveal a stronger consciousness about individual faith with the interviewed people in Crystal Evangelical free Church. There seem to be many people in Freiberg who are not as conscious about their faith in who attach greater importance to all sorts of things. 


I’m unable to hide my sympathies for the structures and activities of the American church. If one considers the fact that both churches do not only have the same biblical assignment, but also nearly the same number of members, it is amazing to see how difficult things are in Germany, while the American church seems to be very dynamic and full of life.

When Pastor Rodquist called it his church’s actual task to spread the gospel and to live for outsiders, it made me very concerned about the situation in my church where internal problems are predominant and nobody seems to care about outsiders. The determination to live the Christian faith which has an impact on all aspects of life can be experienced much better in Crystal Evangelical Free Church, while in Freiberg the church’s status is often that of a traditional ritual.

Für den König

German Folk Worship Song, performed by the worship band Jan plays in.

Johnson Grass

The German folk band Jan plays bass for.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s